Lights, Camera…Libel Action: Avoiding legal challenges after the credits roll
The most compelling stories we see on our screens are sometimes those that carry the greatest legal risks. The TV shows, films and documentaries we all enjoy are a combination of detailed research, excellent storytelling, beautiful camera work and precise editing, but they also involve thorough and careful legal consideration.
Defamation
Libel actions are a key concern for many productions and, if not managed correctly, can result in lengthy (and expensive) legal proceedings. Defamation arises where a statement is published or broadcast that lowers the reputation of the subject, and it isn’t confined to one single statement. Instead, the entire production must be considered to determine if any risk of defamation arises and, if it does, whether any defences might be available – is it true? Is there sufficient evidence to substantiate it? Is it a statement of opinion? Does it concern a matter in the public interest? Has the subject been offered a right of reply?
Privacy
There is a fine balance to be struck between bringing a full and complete story to your audience while respecting the privacy rights of those whose story you are telling. The first consideration is whether the individual has a reasonable expectation of privacy over the information shared. Even if they do, the next step is to consider what the public interest in broadcasting that information is. Issues involving sensitive information, vulnerable adults or children require particular care.
Contempt
As this year has shown, often the most newsworthy stories involve criminal investigations and court proceedings. Arrests, prosecutions and court appearances can be fast paced and the public wants, and deserves, to know what is happening as it happens. But there are significant legal risks in publicising these events and broadcasting too much information too soon risks prejudicing a fair trial and can result in contempt of court.
There are particularly heighten protections for cases involving sexual assault and identifying a victim, even indirectly, can result in a criminal conviction with a custodial sentence.
Reporting restrictions and anonymity orders are also becoming a frequent feature in criminal cases and can significantly restrict the ability to properly report on proceedings. We regularly challenge these applications to ensure the story remains as uncensored, and as newsworthy, as possible.
That’s a Wrap
Whether you’re creating a documentary, a TV show, a feature film or even a podcast, we’re able to help you tell the full story that can withstand any legal challenges long after the credits roll. Seeking legal advice at an early stage in production helps identify and mitigate these risks. But if tight shooting schedules and edit deadlines have pushed pre-broadcast legal clearance down the priority list, we can still provide expert legal advice and representation in the event of a claim – even after the wrap party.
If you would like any further information or advice on the information mentioned within this article, please contact Fergal McGoldrick or Hannah Porter from the Entertainment, Creative & Talent Team.
*This information is for guidance purposes only and does not constitute, nor should be regarded as, a substitute for taking legal advice that is tailored to your circumstances.